What the Milgram obedience study really found (Video)
Written guide: Informed Consent in Research: What It Is and Why It Matters
Full video: Milgram Experiment
In 1963 Stanley Milgram reported that 26 of 40 men went to the last switch on a shock generator; no real shocks were given.
Chapters
- 0:00 Full video
Video transcript
0:00 Full video
Before Stanley Milgram reported his most famous result, he asked 14 Yale seniors to predict the outcome. On average they guessed that about 1 percent of ordinary people would go all the way. The real number was 65 percent, and researchers still argue over what that number means. Milgram worked at Yale, and he recruited 40 men aged 20 to 50 from New Haven and the surrounding communities. Each man was paid 4 dollars and 50 cents, and the money was his no matter what happened after he arrived. Each man was told he was taking part in a learning experiment, and he acted as the teacher. In front of him sat a shock generator with 30 switches, running from 15 volts to 450 volts. For each wrong answer from the learner, he had to raise the shock one step. The teachers did not know two things. The learner was working with the experimenter, and he received no real shocks. When a teacher hesitated, the experimenter used four prods, in order. Please continue. The experiment requires that you continue. It is absolutely essential that you continue. And last, you have no other choice, you must go on. At 300 volts, the learner pounded on the wall and stopped answering. He pounded again after 315 volts, and after that he went silent. No teacher had stopped before 300 volts, and 5 of the 40 refused at that point. In the end, 26 of the 40 men went to the last switch on the generator, 450 volts. Many of them sweated, trembled and stuttered while they did so. The study drew criticism almost at once. In 1964 Diana Baumrind published a critique about the distress to the participants, the deception and the debriefing. The 65 percent also turned out to be one result among many. Milgram ran 23 conditions with 780 participants, and the rate changed with the situation, including how close the teacher was to the learner. Across 21 of those conditions, the overall rate was 43.6 percent. Milgram's assistant Taketo Murata ran an analysis that stayed unpublished. He compared the shocks with what people believed. In 18 of 23 variations, those who fully believed they were causing pain gave lower shocks than those who did not fully believe. Researchers now read the prods differently. The prod most like an order was the least successful. Some researchers argue that people continued because they identified with the science and with the people leading the project. The 65 percent still stands in that first study, and researchers are still working out why those men kept going.