# Clostridial Myonecrosis in Animals: Pathology Guide Clostridial myonecrosis is a rapidly progressive, toxin-mediated necrosis of skeletal muscle caused by histotoxic clostridia, most often *Clostridium perfringens*, *C. septicum*, *C. chauvoei*, *C. novyi*, and *C. sordellii*. The hallmark lesion is emphysematous, dark, foul-smelling muscle with minimal suppuration, driven by exotoxins such as alpha toxin (phospholipase C) and perfringolysin O. This disease matters because it kills fast. In cattle, blackleg can progress from first clinical sign to death in under 48 hours [1]. In sheep and horses, malignant edema following a penetrating wound can do the same. Diagnosis rests on recognizing the characteristic gross and microscopic lesions, confirming gram-positive rods with few leukocytes on cytology, and identifying the organism and its toxin genes by culture and PCR. Treatment is rarely successful once myonecrosis is established, which is why prevention through vaccination and wound management dominates clinical practice. ## What Clostridial Myonecrosis Is and Why It Matters Clostridial myonecrosis is an acute, often fatal infection of skeletal muscle in which anaerobic bacteria produce exotoxins that destroy muscle fibers, blood vessels, and connective tissue while generating gas within the tissue. The infection spreads along fascial planes faster than the immune system can respond, and the resulting toxemia can cause multiorgan failure and death. The disease occurs across species. Cattle develop blackleg from *C. chauvoei* and malignant edema from *C. septicum* or *C. novyi*. Sheep, goats, and horses are susceptible to malignant edema after wounds, injections, or surgery. Pigs and poultry can develop *C. perfringens* myonecrosis under specific conditions. Dogs and cats are less commonly affected but can develop clostridial myositis after deep bite wounds or contaminated injuries. The core pathologic process is the same regardless of species: anaerobic conditions in damaged muscle allow spores or vegetative cells to germinate, toxins diffuse into surrounding tissue, and necrosis outpaces inflammation. This is why the lesion looks so different from a typical bacterial abscess. There is little pus, much gas, and a distinctive rancid odor. ## Causative Species and Their Syndromes Each histotoxic clostridial species has a characteristic host range, route of infection, and toxin profile. The table below summarizes the key comparisons. | Species | Primary Hosts | Syndrome | Key Toxin(s) | Route | |--|--|--|--|--| | *C. perfringens* type A | Cattle, sheep, horses, dogs, humans | Gas gangrene, clostridial myonecrosis | Alpha toxin (phospholipase C), perfringolysin O | Wound contamination, endogenous | | *C. septicum* | Cattle, sheep, horses, pigs | Malignant edema | Alpha toxin (lethal, necrotizing, hemolytic) | Penetrating wounds, endogenous | | *C. chauvoei* | Cattle, sheep | Blackleg (black quarter) | CctA (C. chauvoei toxin A), alpha toxin | Endogenous spores activated by muscle trauma | | *C. novyi* type A | Sheep, cattle, horses | Gas gangrene, malignant edema | Alpha toxin (lethal, necrotizing) | Wound contamination | | *C. novyi* type B | Sheep, cattle | Black disease (infectious necrotic hepatitis) | Beta toxin | Liver fluke migration | | *C. sordellii* | Cattle, sheep, horses | Malignant edema, myonecrosis | Lethal toxin, hemorrhagic toxin | Wound contamination, postpartum | ### Clostridium perfringens Type A *C. perfringens* type A is the most common cause of clostridial myonecrosis in animals and the classic agent of gas gangrene. It produces alpha toxin, a phospholipase C that hydrolyzes phosphatidylcholine and sphingomyelin in cell membranes, and perfringolysin O (theta toxin), a cholesterol-dependent cytolysin that forms pores in cell membranes [2]. Together these toxins cause direct myonecrosis, vascular damage, and hemolysis. Alpha toxin is the primary virulence factor. It induces endothelial cell death by promoting ceramide-mediated apoptosis, which damages blood vessels and impairs blood flow to infected muscle [3]. This vascular injury limits the migration of inflammatory cells into the lesion, explaining the paucity of leukocytes seen on histology [4]. Alpha toxin also inhibits myogenic differentiation of myoblasts, delaying muscle regeneration after infection [5]. Perfringolysin O contributes to tissue destruction and is one of the major extracellular toxins involved in gas gangrene pathogenesis [2]. ### Clostridium septicum *C. septicum* causes malignant edema, a rapidly spreading myonecrosis that follows penetrating wounds, surgical incisions, or intramuscular injections. It produces alpha toxin, a pore-forming toxin that is lethal, necrotizing, and hemolytic. Unlike *C. chauvoei*, *C. septicum* does not typically cause disease through endogenous spore activation in healthy muscle. It requires a breach in the skin or mucosa to establish infection. In cattle and sheep, malignant edema often follows castration, shearing cuts, or injections contaminated with soil or feces. The lesion spreads rapidly along fascial planes, producing crepitant swelling and toxemia. ### Clostridium chauvoei *C. chauvoei* causes blackleg, also called black quarter, a disease of cattle and sheep characterized by necrotizing, hemorrhagic, and emphysematous myositis [6]. The organism is a gram-positive, spore-building anaerobe [7]. Blackleg typically affects young cattle, most commonly between 6 months and 2 years of age, and is endemic in many cattle-raising regions worldwide [8]. The pathogenesis of blackleg differs from malignant edema. Cattle ingest *C. chauvoei* spores from contaminated soil or pasture. Spores cross the intestinal mucosa and are deposited in skeletal muscle and other tissues, where they remain dormant. When muscle trauma occurs, such as from a kick, a fall, or vigorous exercise, the local anaerobic conditions and altered redox potential trigger spore germination. Vegetative bacteria multiply and produce toxins that cause myonecrosis. The primary toxin of *C. chauvoei* is CctA ([Clostridium chauvoei](/knowledge/bacteria/livestock-bacteria/clostridium-chauvoei) toxin A), a beta-barrel pore-forming leukocidin that is an important virulence factor and is conserved across strains from diverse geographic locations over more than 50 years [9]. CctA is fully secreted in culture and induces protective immunity, making it a target for vaccine development [9]. The organism also produces alpha toxin and other virulence factors. Blackleg has been reported to cause intestinal necrosis in calves, a manifestation not previously recognized [6]. In one report, two beef calves aged 3 and 6 months died following acute muscular disease and were found to have sharply demarcated areas of transmural intestinal coagulative necrosis with vascular congestion, hemorrhage, fibrinoid necrosis, and thrombosis [6]. Infection was confirmed by positive *C. chauvoei* immunolabeling and PCR in skeletal muscle and intestine [6]. This finding suggests that systematic examination of the intestines is warranted in blackleg cases. ### Clostridium novyi *C. novyi* type A causes gas gangrene and malignant edema in sheep, cattle, and horses, typically following wound contamination. It produces alpha toxin, a lethal and necrotizing toxin. *C. novyi* type B causes black disease (infectious necrotic hepatitis) in sheep and cattle, a distinct syndrome associated with liver fluke migration that creates anaerobic conditions in the liver. Black disease is not a myonecrosis and is mentioned here only to distinguish it from the myonecrotic syndromes. ### Clostridium sordellii *C. sordellii* causes malignant edema and myonecrosis in cattle, sheep, and horses. It produces lethal toxin and hemorrhagic toxin, which cause severe tissue damage and systemic toxicity. Infections typically follow wounds, surgical procedures, or postpartum contamination of the reproductive tract. ## Pathogenesis: How Toxins Destroy Muscle The pathogenesis of clostridial myonecrosis follows a consistent sequence across species. ### Step 1: Introduction of Spores or Vegetative Cells In malignant edema, contamination of a wound with soil, feces, or saliva introduces spores or vegetative cells into damaged tissue. In blackleg, spores are already present in muscle after hematogenous or lymphatic spread from the intestine, and they remain dormant until triggered. ### Step 2: Anaerobic Conditions and Germination Clostridia are obligate anaerobes. They require low oxygen tension to germinate and multiply. Muscle trauma, vascular compromise, or the presence of facultative anaerobes that consume oxygen create the necessary conditions. In blackleg, muscle trauma from blunt force, overexertion, or intramuscular injection alters local redox potential and triggers germination. ### Step 3: Toxin Production and Tissue Destruction Once vegetative cells are established, they produce exotoxins that diffuse into surrounding tissue. Alpha toxin (phospholipase C) hydrolyzes membrane phospholipids, causing direct cell lysis and increasing vascular permeability. Perfringolysin O forms pores in cholesterol-containing membranes, lysing cells and promoting spread. The combined effect is rapid myonecrosis, vascular thrombosis, and edema. Alpha toxin specifically targets endothelial cells, inducing ceramide-mediated apoptosis and reducing CD31+ endothelial cell counts in infected muscle [3]. This vascular injury impairs blood flow and limits the delivery of inflammatory cells and antibiotics to the site of infection. The result is a lesion that expands faster than the host can mount an effective response. ### Step 4: Gas Production and Crepitus As clostridia ferment carbohydrates and amino acids in damaged tissue, they produce hydrogen, carbon dioxide, and other gases. These gases accumulate in muscle fascicles and subcutaneous tissue, producing crepitant swelling that is palpable on physical examination and visible on imaging. The gas also contributes to the characteristic rancid odor of infected tissue. ### Step 5: Systemic Toxemia Toxins enter the bloodstream and cause systemic effects. In cattle with blackleg, serum aspartate aminotransferase, lactate dehydrogenase, [alkaline phosphatase](/knowledge/molecular-biology/alkaline-phosphatase), alanine aminotransferase, urea, creatinine, creatine kinase, and creatine phosphokinase are significantly elevated compared with healthy animals [10]. These elevations reflect muscle necrosis, liver damage, and renal compromise. Toxemia can progress to shock, multiorgan failure, and death within hours to days. ## Gross Pathology Gross lesions of clostridial myonecrosis are distinctive and often diagnostic when combined with history and signalment. ### Muscle Lesions Affected muscle is swollen, dark red to black, and friable. In blackleg, the muscles are swollen, dark to black, and exhibit crepitation sounds at the time of incision with a rancid odor [10]. The lesion may be confined to a single muscle group or spread along fascial planes. Cut surfaces often reveal straw-colored fluid with gas bubbles [10]. The affected tissue does not have the creamy pus of a typical abscess. Instead, there is serosanguineous exudate, tissue necrosis, and gas. This paucity of suppuration is a direct consequence of toxin-mediated vascular injury and impaired leukocyte migration [4]. ### Subcutaneous and Fascial Lesions Subcutaneous tissue overlying affected muscle is edematous and may be crepitant. In cattle with blackleg, clinically sick animals exhibit fever, lameness, and subcutaneous gaseous swelling and edema, particularly in the hindquarter and front legs [10]. The skin may be discolored, and incisions release gas and foul-smelling fluid. ### Thoracic and Abdominal Cavities In severe cases, serous membranes may show petechial hemorrhages. In blackleg, severe pulmonary edema, myocarditis with petechial hemorrhages, and enlargement and congestion of the liver and spleen have been observed [10]. These findings reflect systemic toxemia and vascular damage. ### Intestinal Lesions A novel presentation of blackleg in calves includes multifocal, transmural intestinal necrosis [6]. The affected intestinal segments show sharply demarcated areas of coagulative necrosis with vascular congestion, hemorrhage, fibrinoid necrosis, and thrombosis [6]. This finding expands the known pathology of *C. chauvoei* infection and suggests that the intestine should be examined in suspected blackleg cases. ## Microscopic Pathology Histologic examination confirms the diagnosis and reveals the characteristic features of clostridial myonecrosis. ### Muscle Necrosis Skeletal muscle fibers show coagulative necrosis with loss of cross-striations, hypereosinophilia, and fragmentation. In blackleg, microscopic examination reveals severe inflammatory reaction, edema, and myonecrosis [10]. The necrosis is often segmental or patchy, reflecting the diffusion of toxins from the site of bacterial proliferation. ### Vascular Lesions Blood vessels in affected muscle show endothelial swelling, thrombosis, and fibrinoid necrosis. Alpha toxin-induced endothelial cell apoptosis reduces capillary density and impairs perfusion [3]. This vascular injury is a key reason why the lesion spreads and why inflammatory cells are scarce. ### Inflammatory Response The inflammatory infiltrate in clostridial myonecrosis is typically sparse and consists mainly of neutrophils and macrophages at the periphery of the lesion. The center of the lesion is often devoid of leukocytes because vascular thrombosis and toxin-mediated cell death prevent their migration [4]. This paucity of suppuration is a diagnostic clue that distinguishes clostridial myonecrosis from pyogenic myositis. ### Gram Stain Findings Gram-stained smears or tissue sections from affected muscle show gram-positive rods with few leukocytes. The bacteria may be seen in chains or singly, often at the periphery of necrotic areas where oxygen tension is lowest. The absence of a robust leukocyte response is a hallmark that should prompt consideration of clostridial myonecrosis. ### Muscle Regeneration When the infection is controlled, muscle regeneration is often deficient. In a murine model of *C. perfringens* myonecrosis, impaired interferon gamma expression, reduced numbers of M1 macrophages, deficient phagocytic activity, and prolonged persistence of inflammatory cells led to deficient muscle regeneration [4]. Transforming growth factor beta 1 expression was associated with collagen accumulation and fibrosis 30 days after infection [4]. These findings suggest that even survivors may have permanent muscle damage. ## Diagnosis Diagnosis of clostridial myonecrosis relies on a combination of clinical signs, gross pathology, cytology, culture, and molecular methods. ### Clinical Signs In cattle with blackleg, clinical signs include fever, lameness, and subcutaneous gaseous swelling and edema, particularly in the hindquarter and front legs [10]. The disease course is typically acute or peracute, with death occurring within 48 hours of onset [1]. However, atypical prolonged courses have been reported, with some animals surviving after intensive treatment [1]. In malignant edema, clinical signs include rapid swelling at the site of a wound, crepitus, and systemic signs of toxemia such as tachycardia, tachypnea, and fever. ### Hematology and Serum Biochemistry Hematologic changes in blackleg include increased erythrocyte sedimentation rate and reduced [red blood cell](/blog/guides/red-blood-cell) count, packed cell volume, leukocyte count, and differential leukocyte count [10]. Serum biochemistry shows significantly elevated aspartate aminotransferase, lactate dehydrogenase, alkaline phosphatase, alanine aminotransferase, urea, creatinine, creatine kinase, and creatine phosphokinase [10]. These changes reflect muscle necrosis, hepatic involvement, and renal compromise. ### Cytology Fine-needle aspiration or impression smears from affected muscle can provide rapid diagnostic information. Gram stain typically shows gram-positive rods with few leukocytes. The presence of large, boxcar-shaped rods in the absence of a suppurative response is highly suggestive of clostridial myonecrosis. ### Culture Anaerobic culture of affected muscle, exudate, or blood can isolate the causative organism. *C. chauvoei* is a gram-positive, spore-building anaerobe that can be cultured from affected tissue [7]. *C. perfringens* grows readily on anaerobic media and produces characteristic double zones of hemolysis on blood agar due to alpha toxin and perfringolysin O. ### PCR and Toxin Typing PCR is the definitive method for identifying the causative species and its toxin profile. In blackleg, diagnosis can be confirmed by PCR on affected muscle and intestine [6]. Toxin typing by PCR identifies the genes encoding alpha toxin, perfringolysin O, CctA, and other virulence factors, allowing precise classification of the isolate. ### Serology Serologic tests can detect antibodies against *C. chauvoei* in cattle. Indirect ELISAs based on whole cell and flagellar antigens have been developed and can detect blackleg-specific antibodies at serum dilutions as low as 1:1600 for whole cell antigens and 1:800 for flagellar antigens without cross-reactions [8]. These assays are useful for evaluating vaccine response and for epidemiologic studies. ### Necropsy Necropsy findings are often diagnostic. In blackleg, necropsy reveals swelling areas containing straw-colored fluid with gas bubbles, swollen dark to black muscles with crepitation and rancid odor, severe pulmonary edema, myocarditis with petechial hemorrhages, and enlargement and congestion of the liver and spleen [10]. Histopathology confirms myonecrosis, vascular lesions, and the presence of gram-positive rods. ## Comparative Notes Across Species ### Cattle Cattle are most commonly affected by blackleg (*C. chauvoei*) and malignant edema (*C. septicum*, *C. novyi*, *C. sordellii*). Blackleg typically affects young cattle aged 6 months to 2 years and is associated with pasture exposure and muscle trauma. Malignant edema follows wounds, injections, or surgery. Both syndromes are acute and often fatal. ### Sheep and Goats Sheep and goats are susceptible to malignant edema, blackleg, and black disease. Blackleg in sheep is less common than in cattle but can occur. Malignant edema often follows shearing cuts, castration, or vaccination. Black disease (*C. novyi* type B) is associated with liver fluke migration and is not a myonecrosis. ### Horses Horses can develop clostridial myonecrosis after penetrating wounds, intramuscular injections, or surgery. *C. perfringens*, *C. septicum*, and *C. sordellii* are common isolates. The disease course is often rapid, and prognosis is poor. ### Pigs Pigs can develop *C. perfringens* type A myonecrosis, often secondary to trauma or surgery. The disease is less commonly reported than in ruminants but can occur in intensive production settings. ### Dogs and Cats Clostridial myonecrosis is uncommon in dogs and cats but can occur after deep bite wounds, contaminated injuries, or surgery. *C. perfringens* and *C. septicum* are the most common isolates. The principles of diagnosis and pathology are similar to those in other species. ## Clinical Relevance, Limitations and Common Mistakes Clostridial myonecrosis is a diagnostic and therapeutic emergency. The disease progresses rapidly, and treatment is often unsuccessful once myonecrosis is established. Prevention through vaccination is the cornerstone of control in endemic areas. Vaccination against *C. chauvoei* is widely practiced in cattle, but the evidence for efficacy is poor to moderate [11]. A polyclostridial vaccine induced a strong specific antibody response and a specific cytokine profile in vaccinated cattle, and all vaccinated animals survived challenge with *C. chauvoei* spores, while unvaccinated controls developed severe disease and died [12]. Neutralizing antibodies against CctA are produced after vaccination, with titers reaching 1000 times 28 days post-vaccination in cattle [9]. These findings support the use of vaccination but highlight the need for continued research into immune mechanisms and vaccine efficacy. Common mistakes in diagnosis and management include the following. Failure to consider clostridial myonecrosis in the differential diagnosis for acute lameness or swelling in cattle. Blackleg can mimic traumatic injury, cellulitis, or other causes of acute lameness. Reliance on culture alone without PCR toxin typing. Culture may be negative if the sample is collected after antibiotic administration or if the organism is present in low numbers. PCR can detect toxin genes directly from tissue. Misinterpretation of the paucity of leukocytes as evidence against infection. The absence of a suppurative response is a hallmark of clostridial myonecrosis, not a reason to exclude it. Failure to examine the intestines in suspected blackleg cases. Intestinal necrosis has been reported in calves with blackleg and may be the only lesion in some cases [6]. Underestimating the speed of disease progression. Blackleg can kill within 48 hours of onset, leaving little time for diagnostic testing or treatment [1]. This article is educational and is not a substitute for veterinary diagnosis or treatment. ## Quick Review 1. Clostridial myonecrosis is caused by histotoxic clostridia, most commonly *C. perfringens*, *C. septicum*, *C. chauvoei*, *C. novyi*, and *C. sordellii*. 2. Alpha toxin (phospholipase C) and perfringolysin O are the major toxins driving myonecrosis, vascular injury, and gas production. 3. Blackleg (*C. chauvoei*) affects young cattle via endogenous spores activated by muscle trauma, while malignant edema follows penetrating wounds. 4. Gross lesions include crepitant, dark, foul-smelling muscle with straw-colored fluid and gas bubbles. 5. Gram stain shows gram-positive rods with few leukocytes, reflecting toxin-mediated vascular injury and impaired leukocyte migration. 6. Culture plus PCR toxin typing confirms the diagnosis and identifies the causative species. 7. Vaccination is the cornerstone of prevention in endemic areas, but evidence for efficacy is poor to moderate. ## Frequently Asked Questions ### What causes clostridial myonecrosis? Clostridial myonecrosis is caused by histotoxic clostridia, primarily *Clostridium perfringens*, *C. septicum*, *C. chauvoei*, *C. novyi*, and *C. sordellii*. These bacteria produce exotoxins that destroy muscle tissue and cause gas production. ### How does blackleg differ from malignant edema? Blackleg is caused by *C. chauvoei* and typically affects young cattle through endogenous spores activated by muscle trauma. Malignant edema is caused by *C. septicum*, *C. novyi*, or *C. sordellii* and follows penetrating wounds or surgical contamination. ### What does Gram stain show in clostridial myonecrosis? Gram stain typically shows gram-positive rods with few leukocytes. The paucity of leukocytes reflects toxin-mediated vascular injury and impaired migration of inflammatory cells into the lesion. ### How is clostridial myonecrosis diagnosed? Diagnosis relies on clinical signs, gross pathology, cytology, anaerobic culture, and PCR toxin typing. PCR is the definitive method for identifying the causative species and its toxin profile. ### Can clostridial myonecrosis be treated? Treatment is often unsuccessful once myonecrosis is established because toxins spread faster than antibiotics can reach the site of infection. Prevention through vaccination and wound management is more effective than treatment. ### Which animals are most at risk? Cattle, sheep, goats, and horses are most commonly affected. Blackleg primarily affects young cattle aged 6 months to 2 years. Malignant edema can affect any species after a penetrating wound or surgical procedure. ## Related Articles - [Interpreting Clinical Pathology Reference Intervals in Laboratory Animals](/knowledge/veterinary-medicine/laboratory-animal-science/interpreting-clinical-pathology-reference-intervals-laboratory-animals) - [Common Diagnostic Pitfalls in Exotic Animal Clinical Pathology](/knowledge/veterinary-medicine/diagnostics/common-diagnostic-pitfalls-in-exotic-animal-clinical-pathology-how-to-avoid-misinterpretation-in-bir) - [Ruminant Clostridial Diseases: Diagnosis and Prevention](/knowledge/veterinary-medicine/clinical-methods/ruminant-clostridial-diseases-diagnosis-prevention) - [Clostridial Necrotic Enteritis in Chickens](/knowledge/bacteria/avian-bacteria/clostridial-necrotic-enteritis-chickens) - [molecular pathology](/blog/careers/molecular-pathology) - [Clostridial Diseases in Livestock: Blackleg, Black Disease, and Enterotoxemia (Pulpy Kidney)](/knowledge/bacteria/livestock-bacteria/clostridial-diseases-livestock-blackleg-black-disease-enterotoxemia) - [Oral Squamous Papilloma: Pathology and Features](/knowledge/veterinary-medicine/veterinary-pathology-microbiology/oral-squamous-papilloma-pathology-and-features) ## Sources 1. [Atypical Prolonged Clinical Course of Blackleg in Nelore Cattle.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42651908/) 2. [Regulation of sialidase production in Clostridium perfringens by the orphan sensor histidine kinase ReeS.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24023881/) 3. [Clostridium perfringens α-toxin specifically induces endothelial cell death by promoting ceramide-mediated apoptosis.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32828915/) 4. [Deficient Skeletal Muscle Regeneration after Injury Induced by a Clostridium perfringens Strain Associated with Gas Gangrene.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31138614/) 5. [Clostridium perfringens α-toxin inhibits myogenic differentiation of C2C12 myoblasts.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32860931/) 6. [Intestinal necrosis in calves with blackleg: A novel presentation of Clostridium chauvoei infection.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42545146/) 7. [Spatial-temporal cluster analysis of fatal Clostridium chauvoei cases among cattle in Styria, Austria between 1986 and 2013.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28237228/) 8. [Comparative evaluation of indirect-ELISAs based on native antigens of Clostridium chauvoei for the detection of blackleg-specific antibodies in cattle.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40451457/) 9. [Production of neutralizing antibodies against the secreted Clostridium chauvoei toxin A (CctA) upon blackleg vaccination.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30771460/) 10. [Pathological and clinical investigations of an outbreak of Blackleg disease due to C. chauvoei in cattle in Punjab, Pakistan.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32074087/) 11. [Evidence-based medicine concerning efficacy of vaccination against Clostridium chauvoei infection in cattle.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22374118/) 12. [Humoral and cellular immune responses in cattle upon Clostridium chauvoei vaccination and challenge.](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40463373/)