Oldest Animals on Earth: Longevity Records and What We Can Learn
The oldest animals on Earth include the Greenland shark, ocean quahog clam, and Aldabra giant tortoise, with verified lifespans ranging from roughly 190 years to more than 500 years. This article examines the species with the longest documented lifespans, the scientific methods used to determine their ages, and the biological mechanisms that support extreme longevity. The content is written for students, researchers, life-science professionals, and informed general readers who want a scientifically grounded comparison of long-lived animals and an explanation of what aging research can learn from them.
At a Glance: Record-Holding Long-Lived Animals
The table below summarizes the most thoroughly documented long-lived animal species, their maximum recorded ages, habitats, and the methods used to determine their ages. These records come from peer-reviewed studies and represent the current scientific consensus.
| Species | Maximum Recorded Age | Primary Habitat | Age Determination Method |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ocean quahog (Arctica islandica) | 507 years | North Atlantic continental shelf | Annual shell growth rings |
| Greenland shark (Somniosus microcephalus) | 392 ± 120 years | Cold North Atlantic and Arctic waters | Radiocarbon dating of eye lens nuclei |
| Bowhead whale (Balaena mysticetus) | Over 200 years | Arctic and sub-Arctic seas | Aspartic acid racemization and harpoon artifacts |
| Aldabra giant tortoise (Aldabrachelys gigantea) | Over 190 years | Aldabra Atoll, Indian Ocean | Historical records and mark-recapture |
| Hydra (Hydra spp.) | Potentially negligible senescence | Freshwater environments worldwide | Laboratory observation of regeneration |
The ocean quahog holds the record as the longest-lived non-colonial animal species, with a reported maximum life span of 507 years. The Greenland shark is the longest-lived vertebrate known to science, with radiocarbon dating of eye lens nuclei revealing a life span of at least 272 years and the largest studied specimen estimated at 392 ± 120 years old. These records come from the peer-reviewed literature and represent the best available evidence for extreme longevity in animals.
The Greenland Shark: The Longest-Lived Vertebrate
The Greenland shark (Somniosus microcephalus) inhabits the cold waters of the North Atlantic and Arctic Ocean and is renowned for its exceptional longevity, with individuals estimated to live for more than 400 years. This deep-sea vertebrate grows slowly and reaches more than 500 centimeters in total length, suggesting a life span well beyond those of other vertebrates. The species has also been proposed as a candidate exhibiting negligible senescence, meaning it shows little to no signs of age-related functional decline.
How Greenland Shark Ages Are Determined
Radiocarbon dating of eye lens nuclei from 28 female Greenland sharks ranging from 81 to 502 centimeters in total length revealed a life span of at least 272 years. Only the smallest sharks, those 220 centimeters or less, showed signs of the radiocarbon bomb pulse, a time marker from the early 1960s. The age at sexual maturity was determined to be at least 156 ± 22 years, and the largest animal studied was 392 ± 120 years old. These findings established the Greenland shark as the longest-lived vertebrate known and raised concerns about species conservation, because populations with such late maturity are particularly vulnerable to overfishing.
The radiocarbon method works because the eye lens nucleus forms during embryonic development and remains metabolically inert throughout the animal's life. The carbon isotope signature in the lens nucleus reflects the environmental carbon at the time of birth, allowing researchers to estimate age even in animals that lack conventional age structures such as otoliths or growth rings.
Reproductive Biology and Conservation Implications
The Greenland shark is viviparous, meaning it gives birth to live young, and a single observation suggests a litter size of about ten. Embryos reach a length of around 40 centimeters at birth, and nutrition is derived from the yolk sac with minimal histotrophy. The gestation period is unknown, but the surface area of the uterus is increased by villi that presumably increase in length with advancing gestation. These villi are not likely to be secretory but play a key role in the oxygen supply to the embryo. Researchers argue that the ability of the uterus to supply oxygen is a limiting factor for litter size, which is not likely to exceed the small number reported in this and other sleeper sharks.
The combination of late sexual maturity, small litter size, and extreme longevity creates a conservation challenge. A species that takes more than 150 years to reach sexual maturity cannot recover quickly from population declines. Management decisions for Greenland shark fisheries must account for these life-history characteristics, and any harvest strategy should be evaluated on time scales that match the species' biology instead of typical fishery management cycles.
The Ocean Quahog: Half a Millennium in a Shell
The ocean quahog (Arctica islandica) is a commercially important bivalve species on the northwestern Atlantic continental shelf. This species can live over 200 years, with the maximum recorded life span reaching 507 years. The ocean quahog is the longest-lived non-colonial animal species known to science.
Age Determination Through Shell Growth Rings
Ocean quahog ages are determined by counting annual growth rings in the shell, similar to counting tree rings. The shell grows incrementally throughout the animal's life, and each year produces a distinct growth band. This method has been validated through cross-dating techniques and radiocarbon analysis, providing reliable age estimates for individual animals.
The first high-quality genome-wide assembly for Arctica islandica was reported in 2025, providing a foundation for understanding the molecular basis of extreme longevity in this species. The genome is estimated at 1781.15 million base pairs with a coverage of 247.8 times. The non-redundant gene set consisted of 39,509 genes, and more than 98% of the genes could be annotated across databases. This genomic resource, along with assemblies from other clam species, sets the stage for elucidating the molecular basis for the convergence of extreme longevity across bivalve species.
Population Demographics and Management Implications
Research on ocean quahog populations from the Mid-Atlantic Bight and Georges Bank has revealed that each site contains a distinct population with distinct demographics. Recruitment is consistent over hundreds of years, but year-to-year and decadal-length variations are apparent. Mortality rates for Georges Bank are distinctly higher compared to other populations, and sex ratios vary, potentially caused by differential survival of one sex during certain times in the past.
These findings have direct implications for fishery management. The use of separate age-length keys is necessary for each population and each sex, because a single age-length relationship cannot accurately represent all populations. Managers assessing ocean quahog stocks should use population-specific growth parameters and account for the spatial heterogeneity in age frequency and recruitment patterns.
Giant Tortoises: Documented Longevity in a Terrestrial Vertebrate
Giant tortoises, particularly the Aldabra giant tortoise (Aldabrachelys gigantea), are among the longest-lived terrestrial vertebrates. Historical records document individuals living more than 190 years, and the existence of very long-lived species including giant tortoises suggests that increased healthy life spans in humans, significantly higher than the current known maximum life span of about 120 years, may be possible.
Age Documentation Methods
Unlike marine species where age determination requires specialized techniques, giant tortoise ages can be documented through historical records, mark-recapture studies, and continuous observation. Some individuals have been tracked from birth to death by researchers and caretakers, providing unambiguous longevity records. The combination of historical documentation and ongoing monitoring programs provides reliable age estimates for these animals.
Biological Significance
Giant tortoises exhibit many characteristics associated with extreme longevity, including slow growth, late sexual maturity, and low metabolic rates. They also experience minimal predation in their native habitats, which aligns with evolutionary theories predicting that reduced extrinsic mortality selects for longer lifespans. The study of giant tortoise biology can inform aging research by identifying the physiological and genetic mechanisms that allow these animals to maintain function over centuries.
Bowhead Whales: Longevity in a Large Marine Mammal
The bowhead whale (Balaena mysticetus) is another species with documented extreme longevity, with individuals living over 200 years. The existence of very long-lived species including the bowhead whale suggests that increased healthy life spans in humans may be possible. Bowhead whales are included in discussions of negligible senescence because they show minimal signs of age-related decline.
Age Determination Methods
Bowhead whale ages are determined through several complementary methods. Aspartic acid racemization in eye lens proteins provides estimates of chronological age, while the recovery of stone harpoon tips embedded in blubber from historical whaling operations provides minimum age estimates for individual animals. These methods have been validated against each other and against known-age animals, providing confidence in the longevity estimates for this species.
Evolutionary Context
The bowhead whale's extreme longevity is consistent with evolutionary theories of aging that predict reduced extrinsic mortality selects for longer lifespans. As a large marine mammal with few natural predators, the bowhead whale experiences low extrinsic mortality, allowing selection to favor mechanisms that maintain function over long periods. The species' large body size and slow metabolic rate may also contribute to its longevity by reducing cumulative physiological stress over time.
Hydra and Negligible Senescence
The small, freshwater organism Hydra spp. is a notable example of negligible senescence, showing no measurable increase in mortality rate with age. Multiple observations that organismal life span can be extended by nutritional, genetic, or pharmacological intervention have raised the prospect of transforming medicine with the goal of slowing, stopping, or even reversing age-associated disease. The potential for such an enterprise is supported in theory by plant and animal models of negligible senescence, most notably Hydra spp.
What Hydra Teaches About Aging
Hydra maintain regenerative capacity throughout their lives, continuously replacing damaged cells and tissues. This capacity is supported by a population of stem cells that divide asymmetrically, producing both replacement stem cells and differentiated cells. The study of Hydra biology can identify the mechanisms that allow sustained tissue maintenance and regeneration, which may inform research on age-related decline in other species.
Limitations of Negligible Senescence Models
While Hydra and other theoretically immortal animals challenge classical assumptions about aging, they also experience extrinsic mortality from predation, disease, and environmental stress. The existence of theoretically immortal animals that experience extrinsic mortality, like planarian flatworms, panther worms, and hydra, further challenges classical assumptions about the inevitability of aging. However, the relevance of these models to human aging remains uncertain, because the biological mechanisms that support regeneration in Hydra may not translate directly to species with complex body plans and limited regenerative capacity.
Evolutionary Theories of Aging and Extreme Longevity
Radical lifespan disparities exist in the animal kingdom. While the ocean quahog can survive for half a millennium, the mayfly survives for less than 48 hours. The evolutionary theories of aging seek to explain why such stark longevity differences exist and why a deleterious process like aging evolved.
Classical Theories and Their Predictions
The classical mutation accumulation, antagonistic pleiotropy, and disposable soma theories predict that increased extrinsic mortality should select for the evolution of shorter lifespans and vice versa. Most experimental and comparative field studies conform to this prediction. Animals with extreme longevity, including the Greenland shark, bowhead whale, giant tortoise, and vestimentiferan tubeworms, typically experience minimal predation.
Challenges to Classical Assumptions
However, data from guppies, nematodes, and computational models show that increased extrinsic mortality can sometimes lead to longer evolved lifespans. The existence of theoretically immortal animals that experience extrinsic mortality further challenges classical assumptions. Octopuses pose another puzzle by exhibiting short lifespans and an uncanny intelligence, the latter of which is often associated with longevity and reduced extrinsic mortality.
The evolutionary response to extrinsic mortality is likely dependent on multiple interacting factors in the organism, population, and ecology, including food availability, population density, reproductive cost, age-mortality interactions, and the mortality source. This complexity means that simple predictions about the relationship between extrinsic mortality and lifespan are insufficient to explain the diversity of longevity patterns observed in nature.
Molecular Mechanisms of Extreme Longevity
Recent genomic studies have identified distinctive features in long-lived species that are consistent with enhanced genome maintenance. The Greenland shark genome, reported in 2026, revealed classical longevity-related mechanisms including immune enhancement, cancer resistance, and DNA repair, as well as additional features potentially associated with extended lifespan limits.
DNA Repair and Genome Stability
The Greenland shark genome contains duplications of DNA repair genes and structural variation in the tumour suppressor protein p53, which are consistent with enhanced genome maintenance, although their functional significance remains to be experimentally validated. Unique amino acid substitutions in the globular domain of linker histone H1.0 are predicted to enhance chromatin stability, and the species' distinctive gene repertoire provides a framework for generating hypotheses potentially linking ferroptosis to exceptional longevity.
Proteostasis and Cellular Homeostasis
Additional mechanisms, such as proteostatic resilience, antioxidant defences, and immune adaptations, may further support long-term cellular homeostasis in the Greenland shark. Collectively, these observations suggest that the Greenland shark possesses biological characteristics that could influence multiple hallmarks of ageing, including genomic stability, proteostasis, and intercellular communication. Emerging evidence also indicates resistance to age-related functional decline in systems such as vision and cardiac function.
Oxidative Stress and Longevity
The free radical theory of ageing predicts that long-lived species should be more resistant to oxidative damage than short-lived species. Although many studies support this theory, recent studies found notable exceptions that challenge the generality of this theory. Analysis of the oxidative status of the Greenland shark found that, as compared to other species, the Greenland shark had body mass-corrected values of muscle glutathione peroxidase and red blood cells protein carbonyls above the 75th percentile and below the 25th percentile, respectively. None of the biochemical metrics of oxidative status measured in either skeletal muscle or red blood cells were correlated with maximum lifespan of species.
Researchers propose that the values of metrics of oxidative status measured in the Greenland shark might be linked to ecological features, such as adaptation to cold waters and deep dives, instead of to its lifespan. This finding challenges simple assumptions about the relationship between oxidative damage and longevity and highlights the need for species-specific investigations.
Comparative Physiology and Metabolic Adaptations
Species that thrive in extreme environments provide insights into resilience, flexibility, and disease resistance. Species such as hibernating brown bears, migratory birds, cavefish, Greenland sharks, and naked mole rats exhibit unique metabolic traits that challenge conventional paradigms of metabolic regulation. These adaptations, including resistance to hypoxia and metabolic ageing, offer potential solutions to human metabolic disorders, including obesity, type 2 diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.
Lessons for Human Health
Insights from comparative physiology, particularly the mechanisms by which animals cope with food scarcity, extreme temperatures, and hypoxia, could help identify novel therapeutic targets for advancing human health. For example, hibernation can serve as a model for understanding metabolic diseases, providing insights into reversible insulin resistance and energy homeostasis. The Greenland shark's slow metabolism and deep-sea habitat provide a natural experiment in extreme metabolic adaptation.
Environmental Threats to Long-Lived Species
Accelerating anthropogenic environmental change threatens even the most resilient animal species. Climate change and other environmental stressors may jeopardise the survival of long-lived species despite their resilience. A holistic approach to conservation and environmental protection is needed to preserve these species and the valuable lessons they offer for managing metabolic health.
Practical Assessment Steps for Longevity Research
Researchers and students studying long-lived animals should follow a systematic approach to ensure accurate age determination and interpretation of longevity records.
Step 1: Select Appropriate Age Determination Methods
Choose age determination methods based on the species and available tissues. For fish with otoliths or other calcified structures, annual growth increment analysis is appropriate. For species lacking conventional age structures, radiocarbon dating of eye lens nuclei or other metabolically inert tissues may be necessary. Validate methods against known-age animals whenever possible.
Step 2: Account for Population Variation
Recognize that age-length relationships and demographic parameters vary among populations. Use population-specific growth parameters and age-length keys instead of applying a single relationship across a species' range. Consider sex-specific differences in growth, mortality, and longevity.
Step 3: Document Uncertainty
Report age estimates with appropriate measures of uncertainty. Radiocarbon dating produces probability ranges instead of exact ages, and these ranges should be reported alongside point estimates. For example, the largest Greenland shark studied was estimated to be 392 ± 120 years old, reflecting substantial uncertainty in the estimate.
Step 4: Integrate Multiple Lines of Evidence
Combine age determination with other biological information, including reproductive status, body size, and genetic data. This integration provides a more complete picture of the species' life history and the factors that contribute to its longevity.
Records and Measurements in Longevity Research
Accurate record-keeping is essential for longevity research and for the management of long-lived species. The following measurements and records should be maintained for studies of long-lived animals.
Essential Measurements
Total length or shell length should be measured using standardized protocols. For sharks, total length is measured from the snout to the tip of the tail. For bivalves, shell length is measured along the anterior-posterior axis. Body weight should be recorded when possible, and tissue samples should be collected for genetic, biochemical, and age determination analyses.
Demographic Records
Population-level records should include age frequency distributions, age-at-length relationships, sex ratios, and mortality rates. These records should be maintained separately for each population and each sex, because demographic parameters vary significantly among populations and between sexes.
Long-Term Monitoring
Long-lived species require monitoring programs that operate on time scales matching the species' biology. A monitoring program for a species that lives 500 years must be designed to detect trends over decades or centuries, beyond years. This requires institutional commitment and stable funding over extended periods.
Common Failure Patterns in Longevity Research
Several common errors can compromise the accuracy and reliability of longevity research. Recognizing these failure patterns is essential for interpreting published records and designing new studies.
Misapplication of Age Determination Methods
Applying age determination methods outside their validated range produces unreliable estimates. For example, using growth increment analysis on species where growth rings are not deposited annually, or applying radiocarbon dating without proper calibration, can produce inaccurate ages. Always validate methods for the specific species and tissue being studied.
Ignoring Population Variation
Assuming that age-length relationships are uniform across a species' range leads to biased demographic estimates. Research on ocean quahogs demonstrated that each site contains a distinct population with distinct demographics, and the use of separate age-length keys is necessary for each population and each sex.
Confusing Correlation with Causation
Observational studies of long-lived species often identify correlations between biological characteristics and longevity, but these correlations do not establish causation. For example, the oxidative status of the Greenland shark differs from other species, but these differences may be linked to ecological features instead of to lifespan. Experimental validation is required before functional significance can be claimed.
Overinterpreting Single Specimens
Maximum longevity records are often based on single individuals, and these records may not represent the typical or potential lifespan of the species. The largest Greenland shark studied was estimated at 392 ± 120 years old, but this estimate has substantial uncertainty and represents only one individual. Multiple specimens and multiple lines of evidence are needed to establish reliable longevity records.
Welfare and Conservation Context
The study of long-lived animals raises important welfare and conservation considerations. Many of the species with extreme longevity are vulnerable to human activities because their life histories make them slow to recover from population declines.
Conservation Status and Threats
The Greenland shark's extreme longevity and late sexual maturity raise concerns about species conservation. A species that takes more than 150 years to reach sexual maturity cannot recover quickly from overfishing or other sources of mortality. Similarly, ocean quahog populations are commercially harvested, and management must account for the species' extreme longevity and slow growth.
Ethical Considerations in Research
Research on long-lived animals should minimize harm to individuals and populations. Non-lethal sampling methods should be used whenever possible, and lethal sampling should be limited to situations where it is scientifically necessary and ethically justified. Researchers should also consider the cumulative impacts of research activities on populations that are already vulnerable due to their life histories.
Climate Change and Long-Term Survival
Accelerating anthropogenic environmental change threatens even the most resilient animal species. Climate change may alter the cold-water habitats that support Greenland sharks and other Arctic species, and ocean warming may affect the distribution and survival of ocean quahogs. Conservation planning must account for these environmental threats alongside direct human impacts.
Professional Escalation Criteria
Researchers, students, and professionals working with long-lived species should recognize when to seek specialized expertise or escalate concerns to appropriate authorities.
When to Consult a Specialist
Consult a specialist in age determination when working with species that lack conventional age structures, when radiocarbon dating or other specialized techniques are required, or when published age estimates conflict with your observations. Specialists in population dynamics should be consulted when developing management recommendations for long-lived species.
When to Report Concerns
Report concerns about population status, illegal harvest, or environmental threats to appropriate conservation authorities. The Greenland shark's late maturity and small litter size make it particularly vulnerable to overfishing, and concerns about population status should be reported promptly. Similarly, unusual mortality events or evidence of habitat degradation should be reported to relevant management agencies.
When to Escalate to Regulatory Authorities
Escalate to regulatory authorities when research activities require permits, when handling protected species, or when findings have direct management implications. Many long-lived species are protected by national and international regulations, and research on these species requires appropriate authorization.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the oldest animal ever recorded?
The ocean quahog (Arctica islandica) holds the record as the longest-lived non-colonial animal species, with a reported maximum life span of 507 years. The Greenland shark is the longest-lived vertebrate known, with radiocarbon dating revealing a life span of at least 272 years and the largest studied specimen estimated at 392 ± 120 years old.
How do scientists determine the age of a Greenland shark?
Scientists use radiocarbon dating of eye lens nuclei. The eye lens nucleus forms during embryonic development and remains metabolically inert throughout the animal's life, so the carbon isotope signature in the lens nucleus reflects the environmental carbon at the time of birth. This method revealed that the age at sexual maturity is at least 156 ± 22 years and that the largest studied specimen was 392 ± 120 years old.
Why do Greenland sharks live so long?
The Greenland shark's extreme longevity may be supported by its extreme environment, low metabolic rate, and remarkably late sexual maturation, all of which may reduce cumulative physiological stress over time. At the molecular level, genomic studies have identified duplications of DNA repair genes and structural variation in the tumour suppressor protein p53, which are consistent with enhanced genome maintenance.
What is negligible senescence?
Negligible senescence refers to the absence of measurable increases in mortality rate with age. The Greenland shark has been proposed as a candidate species exhibiting negligible senescence, and the small freshwater organism Hydra spp. is a notable example. These species show little to no signs of age-related functional decline.
How long can ocean quahogs live?
Ocean quahogs can live over 200 years, with the maximum recorded life span reaching 507 years. This makes the ocean quahog the longest-lived non-colonial animal species known to science. Their ages are determined by counting annual growth rings in the shell.
What can long-lived animals teach us about human aging?
Long-lived species suggest that increased healthy life spans in humans, significantly higher than the current known maximum life span of about 120 years, may be possible. Insights from comparative physiology, particularly the mechanisms by which animals cope with food scarcity, extreme temperatures, and hypoxia, could help identify novel therapeutic targets for advancing human health.
Are all long-lived animals found in cold environments?
Many of the longest-lived animals are found in cold environments, including the Greenland shark, bowhead whale, and ocean quahog. However, giant tortoises live in tropical environments, and Hydra species are found in freshwater worldwide. Cold environments may contribute to longevity by reducing metabolic rate, but they are not the only factor.
Why are long-lived species vulnerable to overfishing?
Long-lived species with late sexual maturity and small litter sizes cannot recover quickly from population declines. The Greenland shark reaches sexual maturity at least 156 ± 22 years and has a litter size of about ten, making it particularly vulnerable to overfishing. Management decisions must account for these life-history characteristics.
Related Articles
- Data Visualization for Biological Research: Choosing Figures That Preserve Meaning
- Animal Research
- biological research
- Scientific Data Provenance For Reproducible Research
- Scientific Data Provenance For Reproducible Research
References and Further Reading
- NCBI Literature Resources. National Center for Biotechnology Information.
- PubMed. National Library of Medicine.
- Potential factors contributing to extreme longevity in the Greenland shark.. Journal of fish biology, 2026.
- Biological Restraints on Indefinite Survival.. Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in medicine, 2023.
- Eye lens radiocarbon reveals centuries of longevity in the Greenland shark (Somniosus microcephalus).. Science (New York, N.Y.), 2016.
- Revamping the evolutionary theories of aging.. Ageing research reviews, 2019.
- Viviparity in the longest-living vertebrate, the Greenland shark (Somniosus microcephalus).. Placenta, 2020.
- Scaling life as an interspecies hallmark of aging.. Genes & development, 2025.
- The Greenland shark genome: Insights into lifespan extremes and population dynamics.. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2026.
- The Greenland shark: A new challenge for the oxidative stress theory of ageing?. Comparative biochemistry and physiology. Part A, Molecular & integrative physiology, 2017.
- Genome-wide association mapping for heat shock tolerance in Mercenaria mercenaria through SNP microarray analysis.. 2025.
- Comparative physiology and biomimetics in metabolic and environmental health: what can we learn from extreme animal phenotypes?. 2026.
- Genome Assembly of <,i>,Arctica islandica<,/i>,, the Longest-Lived Non-Colonial Animal Species.. 2025.
- Examination of spatial heterogeneity in population age frequency and recruitment in the ocean quahog (Arctica islandica Linnaeus 1767). 2022.
- Nonparametric quantile regression captures regional variability and scaling deviations in Atlantic surfclam length-weight relationships.. 2025.
- The Peroxidation of Lipids, Cellular Senescence and Aging.. 2024.
- Sulfonamide resistance evaluation in five animal species and first report of sul4 in companion animals.. Veterinary Microbiology, 2024.
- Authenticity identification of animal species in characteristic milk by integration of shotgun proteomics and scheduled multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) based on tandem mass spectrometry.. Food Chemistry, 2023.
- New dates on dingo bones from Madura Cave provide oldest firm evidence for arrival of the species in Australia. Scientific Reports, 2018.
- Awaiting discovery: How biases in faunistic surveys hinder conservation in mountain protected areas-A case study from Romania’s oldest national park. PLoS ONE, 2025.
- Evolution of animal chemical communication: Insights from non-model species and phylogenetic comparative methods. Belgian Journal of Zoology, 2019.
- RNA analysis of the longest living vertebrate Greenland shark revealed an abundance of LINE-like elements in its transcriptome. Czech Polar Reports, 2023.
- Advancing research for the management of long-lived species: A case study on the Greenland Shark. Frontiers in Marine Science, 2019.
This article is educational and does not replace institutional policy, professional advice, or applicable safety and regulatory requirements.