Are Penguins Mammals? Clearing Up Common Animal Misconceptions

Penguins are birds, not mammals. They belong to the class Aves, order Sphenisciformes, and family Spheniscidae. Penguins possess feathers, lay eggs, and have wings modified for swimming instead of flight. Mammals, by contrast, have hair or fur, produce milk for their young, and give live birth in most cases. This article addresses the classification of penguins, fish, and dolphins to clarify common misconceptions about which animals are mammals.

The confusion often arises because penguins live in cold environments, swim expertly, and share habitats with marine mammals such as seals and whales. Fish are sometimes mistakenly grouped with mammals because both live in water. Dolphins are mammals, not fish, and they share more biological traits with humans and dogs than with sharks or tuna. Understanding these distinctions matters for students, researchers, life-science professionals, and anyone who works with animals in captivity or in the wild.

At a Glance: Mammals, Birds, and Fish Compared

The table below summarizes the key traits that separate mammals, birds, and fish. Use this as a quick reference when identifying animals or teaching others about classification.

Penguins fit every criterion for birds. They have feathers, lay eggs, and are warm-blooded. Dolphins fit every criterion for mammals. They have hair at some stage of life, give live birth, and nurse their young with milk. Fish are a separate class of vertebrates that do not produce milk and generally have gills and scales.

Why Penguins Are Birds, Not Mammals

Penguins are flightless diving birds that are the only extant family of flightless diving birds. They currently comprise at least 18 species distributed from polar to tropical environments in the Southern Hemisphere. Genome-wide analyses have shown that the penguin crown-group originated during the Miocene in New Zealand and Australia, not in Antarctica as previously thought, and that the genus Aptenodytes is the sister group to all other extant penguin species. These findings confirm that penguins are firmly placed within the avian evolutionary tree.

Feathers and Body Covering

All penguins have feathers, which is a defining characteristic of birds. Penguin feathers are dense, short, and stiff, providing insulation and streamlining for swimming. Unlike mammalian fur, penguin feathers grow in distinct tracts and are replaced through molting. The feather structure supports the bird classification regardless of how similar a penguin may appear to a seal or sea lion at a distance.

Egg Laying and Reproduction

Penguins lay eggs, a trait shared with all birds but not with mammals. Female penguins typically lay one or two eggs per breeding season, depending on the species. Both parents often share incubation duties. The egg-laying reproductive strategy is fundamentally different from the live birth and lactation that define mammals.

Wings and Locomotion

Penguin wings are modified for underwater flight. Ecomorphological studies of the penguin wing show that penguins are pursuit divers that feed mainly on krill, fish, and squid. Their wing musculature is responsible for maneuverability and strength while diving. Research on wing morphology across all extant penguin species found that morphological differences among penguins with different diets are significant, with the greatest differences found between piscivorous and crustacivorous penguins. This wing structure is a bird adaptation, not a mammalian limb.

Warm-Blooded Metabolism

Penguins are endothermic, meaning they maintain a constant internal body temperature. This trait is shared with mammals and other birds but distinguishes them from most fish. Penguins have evolved sophisticated thermoregulation strategies. A mathematical model of huddling penguins demonstrated that individual penguins in a huddle seek only to reduce their own heat loss, with boundary penguins moving downwind to sheltered locations while interior penguins remain stationary. This collective behavior allows penguins to survive extreme cold while maintaining their warm-blooded metabolism.

Are Fish Mammals?

Fish are not mammals. Fish belong to various classes within the vertebrate subphylum, including Chondrichthyes for sharks and rays and Actinopterygii for ray-finned fishes. Mammals belong to the class Mammalia. The two groups differ in fundamental anatomical, physiological, and reproductive traits.

Key Differences Between Fish and Mammals

Fish breathe through gills, while mammals breathe through lungs. Most fish are ectothermic, meaning their body temperature matches their environment, while mammals are endothermic. Fish reproduce by laying eggs in most species, while mammals give live birth in most species. Fish do not produce milk, and they lack the mammary glands that define mammals.

Why the Confusion Occurs

The confusion between fish and mammals likely arises because both groups include animals that live in water. Dolphins and whales are mammals that live in the ocean, and some people assume all aquatic animals are fish. However, dolphins and whales breathe air, give live birth, and nurse their young, making them mammals despite their aquatic habitat.

Sharks and Other Cartilaginous Fish

Sharks are fish, not mammals. They have skeletons made of cartilage instead of bone, breathe through gills, and are ectothermic in most species. Some sharks give live birth, which can add to the confusion, but live birth alone does not make an animal a mammal. The presence of gills, scales, and the absence of mammary glands confirm that sharks are fish.

Are Dolphins Mammals?

Dolphins are mammals. They belong to the order Cetacea, which includes whales, dolphins, and porpoises. Dolphins share all the defining traits of mammals: they are warm-blooded, breathe air through lungs, give live birth, and nurse their young with milk produced by mammary glands.

Cetacean Biology and Classification

Cetaceans are fully aquatic mammals that evolved from land-dwelling ancestors. They have streamlined bodies, flippers, and tail flukes adapted for life in water. Despite their fish-like appearance, cetaceans retain mammalian traits such as hair at some stage of life, typically present as small hairs on the rostrum of newborns. They also have a four-chambered heart, a diaphragm, and a neocortex in the brain, all mammalian characteristics.

Reproduction and Lactation in Dolphins

Female dolphins give live birth to a single calf after a gestation period that varies by species. The calf nurses from its mother for an extended period, receiving milk that is rich in fat and protein. Research on cetacean mammary glands has highlighted their fundamental role in providing vital nutrients for the growth of offspring. The presence of functional mammary glands and lactation is a defining feature of mammals that fish do not possess.

Dolphin Communication and Social Behavior

Dolphins are highly social marine mammals that use acoustic communication. Many delphinids rely on frequency-modulated tonal signals known as whistles for social communication. Individually distinctive signature whistles have been extensively studied in bottlenose dolphins over the past 60 years. These stereotyped whistles convey individual identity and motivational information. This complex communication system is consistent with the advanced cognitive abilities typical of mammals.

Health and Disease in Dolphins

Dolphins face health challenges that are relevant to their classification and care. Cetacean morbilliviruses have emerged as significant pathogens affecting cetacean populations worldwide. A genome sequence of Fraser's dolphin morbillivirus isolated from a stranded Fraser's dolphin in Hawai'i showed that this virus is a distinct member of the genus Morbillivirus, branching as the most basal member of the cetacean morbillivirus clade. Fungal infections also affect dolphins, with Candida albicans considered one of the most significant fungal pathogens in cetaceans. These disease patterns are studied within veterinary medicine for mammals, further confirming the mammalian status of dolphins.

The Biological Classification System

Understanding animal classification requires knowledge of the taxonomic hierarchy. All animals are classified into groups based on shared evolutionary ancestry and physical traits.

Taxonomic Ranks

The primary taxonomic ranks are domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, and species. Penguins and dolphins share the ranks of domain, kingdom, phylum, and subphylum. Both are eukaryotes, animals, chordates, and vertebrates. They diverge at the class level, with penguins in Aves and dolphins in Mammalia.

Class Aves

Class Aves includes all birds. Birds are characterized by feathers, beaks without teeth, hard-shelled eggs, and a high metabolic rate. Penguins are one of the most derived groups of birds, having evolved flightlessness and specialized adaptations for aquatic life. Their wings have become flippers, and their bodies are streamlined for efficient swimming.

Class Mammalia

Class Mammalia includes all mammals. Mammals are characterized by mammary glands, hair, three middle ear bones, and a neocortex. Dolphins possess all these traits. The presence of mammary glands is the defining feature that gives the class its name.

Class Actinopterygii and Other Fish Classes

Fish are not a single class but a collection of classes within the subphylum Vertebrata. Ray-finned fishes belong to Actinopterygii, lobe-finned fishes belong to Sarcopterygii, and cartilaginous fishes belong to Chondrichthyes. These classes are distinct from Mammalia and Aves.

Penguin Biology and Ecology

Penguins have unique biological and ecological characteristics that make them fascinating subjects of study. Understanding these traits helps clarify why they are birds and provides practical knowledge for those who work with penguins in captivity.

Penguin Diet and Foraging

Penguins are pursuit divers that feed mainly on krill, fish, and squid. A comprehensive dataset on worldwide penguin diet compiled dietary data for 17 out of 19 currently recorded penguin species, spanning the period from 1980 to 2019 and covering 149 global locations. The dataset includes 2,749 dietary entries with qualitative and quantitative information on prey types. Key prey groups include fish from the class Teleostei, crustaceans from the class Malacostraca, and mollusks from the class Cephalopoda. The Adélie Penguin and the Magellanic Penguin are the most extensively studied species.

Penguin Morphology and Adaptation

Penguins have evolved specialized morphology for their aquatic lifestyle. Ecomorphological studies comparing the Humboldt Penguin and Magellanic Penguin found that both species generally overlapped in trait morphology, but Magellanic Penguins showed greater trait diversity. Wing morphology was more homogenous between species than beak morphology, indicating a similar mode of locomotion but potential differences in prey procurement. These findings support a potentially optimal wing design for aquatic movement that likely applies to other penguin species.

Penguin Thermoregulation

Penguins maintain their body temperature through a combination of insulation, behavior, and physiology. The huddling behavior of emperor penguins is a remarkable example of collective thermoregulation. A mathematical model of huddling penguins demonstrated that individual penguins seeking to reduce their own heat loss produce a cumulative effect where all penguins have approximately equal access to the warmth of the huddle. The key parameters affecting huddle dynamics are the number of penguins in the huddle, wind strength, and the amount of uncertainty in penguin movement.

Penguin Vision and Sensory Adaptations

Penguins have visual adaptations suited to their aquatic environment. Research on the corneal structure of three penguin species has examined the confocal and electron microscopic structure of the cornea. These studies contribute to understanding how penguins see both in air and underwater, an adaptation necessary for their foraging behavior.

Practical Assessment: Identifying Mammals, Birds, and Fish

For students, researchers, and professionals who need to identify animals correctly, a systematic approach is useful. The following steps provide a practical framework for classification.

Step 1: Observe Body Covering

Examine the animal's external covering. Feathers indicate a bird. Hair or fur indicates a mammal. Scales indicate a fish or reptile. Penguins have feathers, even though they may appear smooth and sleek. Dolphins have smooth skin with minimal hair, but they are mammals based on other traits.

Step 2: Assess Reproductive Method

Determine how the animal reproduces. Egg laying is common in birds and most fish. Live birth occurs in most mammals and some fish. The presence of mammary glands and milk production is unique to mammals. Dolphins nurse their young, confirming their mammalian status.

Step 3: Evaluate Respiratory System

Observe how the animal breathes. Gills extract oxygen from water and are found in most fish. Lungs extract oxygen from air and are found in mammals and birds. Dolphins and whales must surface to breathe, confirming they have lungs. Penguins also have lungs and must breathe air.

Step 4: Check Body Temperature Regulation

Determine whether the animal is endothermic or ectothermic. Mammals and birds are endothermic, maintaining a constant internal temperature. Most fish are ectothermic, with body temperature matching the environment. Penguins and dolphins are both endothermic.

Step 5: Confirm with Multiple Traits

Use multiple traits to confirm classification. A single trait can be misleading. For example, some sharks give live birth, but they are fish because they have gills, scales, and no mammary glands. Penguins swim like dolphins, but they have feathers, lay eggs, and have wings, making them birds.

Records and Measurements for Animal Classification

Maintaining accurate records is essential for researchers, wildlife managers, and veterinary professionals. The following measurements and observations support correct classification and provide data for scientific studies.

Morphometric Measurements

Standard morphometric measurements include body mass, tarsus length, beak dimensions, wing loading, and aspect ratio. These measurements were used in ecomorphological studies of South American penguins to compare species and detect local adaptations. For penguins, wing loading and aspect ratio are particularly relevant because they relate to swimming efficiency.

Behavioral Observations

Behavioral observations provide evidence for classification. Nest building, egg incubation, and chick rearing are bird behaviors. Nursing, live birth, and social learning are mammal behaviors. Dolphin whistle studies have documented repeated whistle types that function in social communication, providing evidence of complex mammalian social behavior.

Health and Disease Records

Health records contribute to understanding animal biology and classification. Avian malaria is a mosquito-borne disease caused by protozoans of the genus Plasmodium and is considered one of the most important causes of morbidity and mortality in captive penguins. Outbreaks have been associated with mortality as high as 50 to 80 percent of affected captive populations within a few weeks. This disease affects penguins as birds, and its management requires avian veterinary knowledge.

Environmental Monitoring

Environmental monitoring supports conservation and classification efforts. Active surveillance for influenza virus and coronavirus infection in Antarctic birds and mammals has been conducted using environmental fecal samples. During the summer of 2021 to 2022, researchers collected and examined 315 fecal samples to target respiratory viruses. Although the viruses of interest were not detected during that expedition, previous research showed the presence of the H11N2 subtype of influenza A virus in penguin fecal samples from the same region.

Common Misconceptions and Failure Patterns

Misclassification of animals occurs for several identifiable reasons. Recognizing these patterns helps prevent errors in educational, research, and professional settings.

Misconception 1: All Aquatic Animals Are Fish

This misconception leads people to classify dolphins, whales, and penguins as fish. The reality is that aquatic habitat does not determine classification. Dolphins are mammals, penguins are birds, and only animals with fish anatomy are fish.

Misconception 2: Live Birth Means Mammal

Some fish, including certain sharks, give live birth. This leads some people to classify them as mammals. However, live birth is not exclusive to mammals. The presence of mammary glands and milk production is the defining mammalian trait.

Misconception 3: Cold Environments Mean Mammal

Penguins live in cold environments and have thick body coverings, leading some people to assume they are mammals. However, insulation strategy does not determine classification. Penguins have feathers and lay eggs, making them birds regardless of their cold habitat.

Misconception 4: Swimming Ability Means Fish

Penguins and dolphins are both excellent swimmers, leading some people to classify them together. However, swimming ability is an ecological adaptation, not a taxonomic trait. Penguins are birds that swim with their wings, and dolphins are mammals that swim with their flippers and tail.

Misconception 5: Lack of Visible Hair Means Not Mammal

Dolphins appear hairless, leading some people to question their mammalian status. However, dolphins have hair at some stage of life, typically as newborns. Hair may be sparse or present only briefly, but its presence at any life stage confirms mammalian classification.

Welfare and Safety Context for Penguins and Dolphins

Understanding the classification of penguins and dolphins has practical implications for their care in captivity and conservation in the wild.

Penguin Health Management in Captivity

Penguins in captivity face specific health challenges that require avian veterinary expertise. Avian malaria is a significant threat, with outbreaks causing high mortality in affected captive populations. Aspergillosis is another major fungal infection in penguins, and captive penguins are particularly susceptible. A multidisciplinary aspergillosis control team implemented preventive measures including minimizing contact between captive penguins and soil, washing penguin feet after outdoor marches, and cleaning facilities with sodium hypochlorite and hot water. These measures resulted in no incidence of aspergillosis in captive penguins since 2016.

Pharmacokinetic Considerations for Penguins

Drug dosing in penguins requires species-specific consideration. A systematic review of pharmacokinetics in penguin species compared with other avian species found that penguin pharmacokinetics differs from other avian species, with weight-adjusted AUC and Cmax values higher than most other avian species. For enrofloxacin, the AUC in the African penguin is 85.7 micrograms hours per milliliter, which is more than double the other bird species studied. This finding highlights the importance of species-specific pharmacokinetic data for optimal therapy.

Dolphin Health and Disease Surveillance

Dolphins in captivity and the wild face health challenges that require mammalian veterinary care. Fungal infections in cetaceans include Candida albicans and non-albicans Candida species. The most important predisposing factors are immunosuppression, long-term antibiotic treatment, environmental stress factors, and deterioration of water quality. Diagnostic methods are based on cytology, histopathology, culture, and molecular methods. Treatment is mostly composed of systemic azole antifungals, although with high levels of therapeutic failure.

Conservation and Ecotourism

Penguins and dolphins are both affected by human activities. Ecotourism can have net positive or negative effects on threatened species depending on population parameters, starting sizes, predation, and ecotourism scale and mechanisms. For the African penguin, tourism can extend expected survival time in some cases, but tourism does not currently overcome other major conservation threats associated with natural resource extractive industries.

Environmental Contaminants

Aquatic mammals and penguins can accumulate metals in their tissues. Studies of metal concentrations in the liver and kidney of aquatic mammals and penguins provide data for monitoring environmental contamination. These studies inform conservation and public health decisions.

Professional Escalation Criteria

When working with penguins, dolphins, or other animals, certain situations require professional intervention. The following criteria indicate when to escalate to a veterinarian, wildlife specialist, or other qualified professional.

Escalation for Penguin Health Concerns

Seek professional veterinary care if a penguin shows signs of illness including lethargy, reduced appetite, respiratory distress, or unusual behavior. Avian malaria and aspergillosis can progress rapidly, and early intervention is critical. If multiple penguins in a captive population show symptoms simultaneously, escalate immediately because outbreaks can cause mortality as high as 50 to 80 percent of affected populations within a few weeks.

Escalation for Dolphin Health Concerns

Seek professional veterinary care if a dolphin shows signs of illness including skin lesions, abnormal breathing, reduced appetite, or changes in behavior. Fungal infections can progress from localized mucocutaneous infections to fatal systemic disease, with mortality rates approaching 100 percent in severe cases despite therapeutic treatment. Skin lesions in dolphins should be evaluated by professionals who can determine whether they are pathogenic, opportunistic, or indicators of poor health or water quality.

Escalation for Classification Disputes

If there is disagreement about the classification of an animal, consult authoritative taxonomic references or a qualified biologist. Classification disputes in educational or professional settings should be resolved using evidence from anatomy, genetics, and reproductive biology instead of anecdotal observations.

Escalation for Conservation Decisions

Conservation decisions affecting penguins or dolphins should involve professionals with relevant expertise. Habitat modeling, population viability analysis, and ecotourism impact assessment require specialized training. For example, habitat models have been used to identify marine Important Bird and Biodiversity Areas for Chinstrap Penguins in the South Orkney Islands, providing a method for designating conservation priority sites when tracking data are not available.

Limitations of Classification Knowledge

Classification is based on current scientific understanding, which evolves as new evidence emerges. Several limitations should be acknowledged.

Genetic Evidence and Classification

Genome-wide analyses have revised understanding of penguin evolutionary history. The finding that the penguin crown-group originated in New Zealand and Australia instead of Antarctica demonstrates that genetic evidence can overturn previous assumptions. Classification based on morphology alone may be incomplete without genetic confirmation.

Species Diversity and Data Gaps

The number of recognized penguin species has changed over time, with current estimates ranging from 18 to 19 species. The Penguin Diet Dataset includes data for 17 out of 19 currently recorded penguin species, highlighting gaps in knowledge for understudied species, regions, and time periods. Similar data gaps exist for many marine mammals.

Regional Variation

Morphological traits can vary within species across geographic ranges. Studies of South American penguins found that local adaptation was common in other traits, with Punta Norte in Argentina often distinct in having high variation in beak depth, wing loading, and wing shape. Classification based on traits from one region may not apply to the same species in another region.

Emerging Diseases

New diseases and pathogens continue to emerge, affecting our understanding of animal health and classification. Active surveillance for influenza virus and coronavirus infection in Antarctic birds and mammals is ongoing, and continuous monitoring is crucial given the continuous emergence of new viral strains worldwide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are penguins mammals?

No, penguins are birds. They belong to the class Aves and order Sphenisciformes. Penguins have feathers, lay eggs, and have wings modified for swimming. They do not have mammary glands and do not produce milk for their young.

Is a bird a mammal?

No, a bird is not a mammal. Birds belong to the class Aves, while mammals belong to the class Mammalia. Birds have feathers, lay hard-shelled eggs, and do not produce milk. Mammals have hair or fur, give live birth in most species, and produce milk for their young.

Are fish mammals?

No, fish are not mammals. Fish belong to various classes within the subphylum Vertebrata, including Actinopterygii for ray-finned fishes and Chondrichthyes for sharks and rays. Fish breathe through gills, are ectothermic in most species, and do not produce milk. Mammals breathe through lungs, are endothermic, and produce milk.

Are dolphins mammals?

Yes, dolphins are mammals. They belong to the order Cetacea, which includes whales, dolphins, and porpoises. Dolphins are warm-blooded, breathe air through lungs, give live birth, and nurse their young with milk produced by mammary glands.

Is a dolphin a mammal?

Yes, a dolphin is a mammal. Despite living in water and having a fish-like appearance, dolphins possess all the defining traits of mammals, including hair at some stage of life, live birth, and milk production for their young.

Why do people confuse penguins with mammals?

People confuse penguins with mammals because penguins live in cold environments, swim expertly, and share habitats with marine mammals such as seals and whales. Penguins also have a thick body covering that can resemble fur from a distance. However, penguins have feathers, lay eggs, and have wings, making them birds.

Do penguins have feathers or fur?

Penguins have feathers. Penguin feathers are dense, short, and stiff, providing insulation and streamlining for swimming. Feathers are a defining characteristic of birds and are structurally different from mammalian fur or hair.

Do dolphins lay eggs?

No, dolphins do not lay eggs. Dolphins give live birth to a single calf after a gestation period that varies by species. The calf nurses from its mother for an extended period. Live birth and lactation are defining traits of mammals.

Related Articles

• Animal Biology
• Animal Research
• Classification Biology
• Biology Classification
• Metagenomic Taxonomic Classification

References and Further Reading

• NCBI Literature Resources. National Center for Biotechnology Information.
• PubMed. National Library of Medicine.
• Modeling huddling penguins.. PloS one, 2012.
• Ecomorphology of South American Penguins.. Journal of morphology, 2025.
• Malaria in penguins - current perceptions.. Avian pathology : journal of the W.V.P.A, 2016.
• Ecomorphological variation of the penguin wing.. Journal of morphology, 2023.
• Genome-wide analyses reveal drivers of penguin diversification.. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2020.
• Pharmacokinetics in Penguins Compared to Other Avian Species: A Review of Enrofloxacin and Voriconazole.. Molecular pharmaceutics, 2023.
• A dataset on worldwide penguin diet.. Scientific data, 2025.
• [Countermeasures Against Aspergillosis in Captive Penguins].. Medical mycology journal, 2022.
• Genome sequence of Fraser's dolphin morbillivirus isolated from a stranded Fraser's dolphin (Lagenodelphis hosei) in Hawai'i.. 2026.
• Candida Infections in Marine Mammals: Epidemiology, Antifungal Resistance, and One Health Implications.. 2026.
• An exploratory investigation into the microbial and cyanobacterial presence on skin epibiotia and orofacial lesions in estuarine common bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) through metabarcoding.. 2026.
• Identification and classification of repeated whistle types from free-ranging rough-toothed dolphins (Steno bredanensis).. 2026.
• Imaging and Diagnostic Tools for Cetacean Mammary Gland Assessment: Challenges and Future Directions for Marine Mammal Pathology, Medicine and Research.. 2025.
• Tracing nutrient allocation in capital breeding baleen whales using amino acid stable isotope analysis: a novel method to infer protein balance and reproductive status.. 2025.
• BIRD AND MAMMAL OBSERVATIONS ON ADAMS ISLAND AND SOUTHERN AUCKLAND ISLAND 1989. 1989.
• Using habitat models to identify marine important bird and biodiversity areas for Chinstrap Penguins Pygoscelis antarcticus in the South Orkney Islands. Polar Biology, 2018.
• Using habitat models to identify marine Important Bird and Biodiversity Areas for Chinstrap penguins in the South Orkney Islands. 2019.
• Net Effects of Ecotourism on Threatened Species Survival. PLoS ONE, 2016.
• Active surveillance for influenza virus and coronavirus infection in Antarctic birds and mammals in environmental fecal samples, South Shetland Islands.. Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências, 2023.
• DIVING BEHAVIOR OF THE EMPEROR PENGUIN. 2003.
• Emperor penguin colony at Cape Washington, Antarctica. Polar Record, 1990.
• Are penguins and seals in competition for Antarctic krill at South Georgia?. 2002.
• Metal concentrations in the liver and kidney of aquatic mammals and penguins. Biological Trace Element Research, 2004.
• Biomass of birds and mammals in the Ross Sea.. Antarctic Nutrient Cycles and Food Webs, 1985.
• Stomach flushing does not affect apparent adult survival, chick hatching, or fledging success in yellow-eyed penguins (Megadyptes antipodes). Biological Conservation, 2016.
• Recolonization of Robben Island by African penguins, 1983-1992. Penguins, 1995.
• Confocal and Electron Microscopic Structure of the Cornea from Three Species of Penguin. Vision Switzerland, 2023.

This article is educational and does not replace institutional policy, professional advice, or applicable safety and regulatory requirements.